Cicero
IN
Average Sales Price
$606,941
Median Sales Price
$374,900
Population
7,591
Total Listings
29
Discover Life in Cicero with Karen Sauer
Local Perspective
If I were walking a client through Cicero, I’d point out how this lakeside town feels like a hidden gem just north of Indy—a place where neighbors still wave and weekends are often spent outdoors. Cicero stands out in our broader Hamilton County market for its relaxed, small-town spirit paired with easy access to Morse Reservoir. I often recommend Cicero to clients who want the balance of peaceful living and a sense of community, all without feeling too far removed from city amenities. It’s a spot where you can truly slow down, but still stay connected to the opportunities of the greater Indianapolis area.
Neighborhood Highlights
The atmosphere in Cicero is welcoming and unhurried, with a genuine Hoosier friendliness you notice right away. What makes Cicero distinct from nearby towns is its lakeside lifestyle—there’s a strong sense of community built around the reservoir, local festivals, and family-run businesses downtown. The vibe here is undeniably family-oriented and outdoorsy, with plenty of folks taking advantage of boating, fishing, and scenic walking trails. At the same time, you’ll find a creative energy in the way residents support local shops and events, making it a lively yet laid-back place to call home.
Homes & Architecture
Cicero offers a mix of home styles, from classic ranches and split-levels to newer construction with open-concept layouts. You’ll see charming mid-century homes with mature trees, as well as updated lakefront properties that take full advantage of water views. Many homes here feature spacious yards and porches—perfect for summer evenings or backyard gatherings. Whether you’re drawn to a cozy bungalow or a contemporary build near the water, Cicero’s housing options tend to reflect the area’s easygoing, practical character.
Demographics
Data provided by Attom Data
Population
Employment
Population
7.6K
7.6K in 2020
Density
258.4
per square mile
Households
3K
Total households
Gender
51% / 49%
Men Vs Women
Occupancy
84% / 16%
Owned Vs Rented
Age Median: Years
Education Level
Educational Environment
Elementary Schools (1)Middle Schools (1)
Name
Category
Grades
Library
Ratio
0/10
Cicero Seventy-Day Adventist Elementary School
24089 State Road 19, Cicero, IN 46034
Private
1 - 8
Yes
12:1 STUDENTS/TEACHERS
Amenities & Attractions
Featured Listings
For Sale (26)
Sold (1506)
New4 Beds2 Baths2,238 SqFt190 W Cass ST, Cicero, IN 46034
Listed by Kristy Huntwork of Vision One Real Estate
Active3 Beds2 Baths10,346 SqFt23702 Anthony RD #23710, Cicero, IN 46034
Listed by Kelsay Bolden of T&H Realty Services, Inc.
Active3 Beds2 Baths1,143 SqFt940 Beacon LN, Cicero, IN 46034
Listed by Isabella Frazier of Trelora Realty
Active3 Beds3 Baths4,211 SqFt600 Lakeview LN, Cicero, IN 46034
Listed by Mindy Garcia of CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Active2 Beds1 Bath1,596 SqFt339 W Cass ST, Cicero, IN 46034
Listed by Suzi Leidenfrost of Real Broker, LLC
Active3 Beds2 Baths1,456 SqFt141 Sunset CT, Cicero, IN 46034
Listed by Lisa Kercheval Aerne of F.C. Tucker Company
Cicero Living: What Buyers Need To Know
To help you make informed decisions, we've compiled answers to some of the most commonly asked questions.
What types of homes are common in Cicero?
In Cicero, you’ll find a mix of single-family homes, lakefront properties, and newer subdivisions. There’s a blend of established neighborhoods and newer developments, so options range from cozy ranches to spacious two-stories. I’m always happy to help you match your needs with the right style.
How is the commute and connectivity from Cicero?
Is Cicero walkable, and what’s the lifestyle like?
How fast do homes sell in Cicero?
What should I know about schools in Cicero?
Are there HOAs or extra fees in Cicero neighborhoods?
